Description

Narrative analysis is a research methodology that is primarily used in qualitative research with the goal of understanding research participants’ “self-generated meanings” (Flick, 2014, p. 204). Narrative analysis uses participants’ voices and the events that participants describe as occurring in their lives in order to construct a chronological story from the data (Franzosi, 1998). Narrative analysis is seen as particularly helpful in conveying how the participants’ lived experiences, including their self-perceptions, perceptions of events, and perceptions of others, informs their understanding of themselves and the world, and it is rooted in a variety of narrative theories that help those engaging in narrative analysis identify different structures for generating stories out of data (Herman & Vervaeck, 2005). Not only does narrative analysis lend itself well to critical and interpretivist paradigms, but it is also seen as a particularly useful tool for ethnographers. The majority of researchers who employ narrative analysis methodologies do so because they want to understand the many contradictions and layers of meaning found in narratives as well as to understand how “narratives operate dialogically between the personal and the surrounding social worlds that produce, consume, silence and contest them” (Flick, 2014, p. 204). Therefore, narrative analysis offers researchers the opportunity to deconstruct participants’ stories and to recontextualize them within the larger social world, which can prove helpful to both interpretivist and critical paradigms that hope to explore and, potentially, contend misperceptions about those being studied.

Not only does narrative analysis lend itself well to critical and interpretivist paradigms, but it is also seen as a particularly useful tool for ethnographers. Specifically, since ethnographers frequently employ participant interviews as the tool for constructing an understanding of social phenomena and social locations, narrative analysis can provide a unique lens for ethnographers to place participants’ stories at the center of their research (Franzosi, 1998). Moreover, ethnographers have often been criticized for reifying existing stereotypes and misperceptions of their research participants. Narrative analysis, therefore, is seen as a potential strategy for ensuring that participants are the ones sharing their stories as opposed to the researchers sharing their interpretations of participants’ experiences (Gubrium & Holstein, 1999; Kim, 2016).

References

Flick, U. (2014). The SAGE handbook of qualitative data analysis. London, England: SAGE.

Franzosi, R. (1998). Narrative analysis: Or why (and how) sociologists should be interested in narrative. Annual Review of Sociology, 24, 517-554. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.soc.24.1.517

Gubrium, J. F., & Holstein, J. A. (1999). At the border of narrative and ethnography. Journal of  Contemporary Ethnography, 28(5), 561–573. https://dx.doi-org/10.1177/089124199129023550

Herman, L., & Vervaeck, B. (2005). Handbook of narrative analysis. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.

Kim, J.-H. (2016). Understanding narrative inquiry: The crafting and analysis of stories as research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

Key Research Books and Articles on Narrative Analysis Methodology

Franzosi, R. (1998). Narrative analysis: Or why (and how) sociologists should be interested in narrative. Annual Review of Sociology, 24, 517-554. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.soc.24.1.517

In this paper, Franzosi makes the case for why sociologists should consider narrative analysis methodologies, suggesting that narrative analysis naturally aligns with the field of sociology. Franzosi asserts that since much of the empirical data that sociologists collect is inherently written as narrative, it is only natural for sociologists to utilize narrative analysis as a methodological approach to their research. Moreover, because Franzosi provides a clear working definition of narrative analysis, then walks readers through analysis of a narrative text, this paper is a useful tool not just for sociologists but for all academics interested in narrative analysis and looking for clarity on how one might engage in the narrative analysis of text.

Gubrium, J. F., & Holstein, J. A. (1999). At the border of narrative and ethnography. Journal of  Contemporary Ethnography, 28(5), 561–573. https://dx.doi-org/10.1177/089124199129023550

In this article, Gubrium and Holstein assert that researchers often exist between the borders of ethnographic and narrative methodologies, and that, in the future, rather than delineating clear borders between these methodologies, researchers should instead become comfortable existing within the tensions of this border. Specifically, the argument is made that ethnographic research has been criticized for often reifying existing stereotypes or misunderstandings of those being studied rather than presenting an interpretation of the participants and their spaces/places through the eyes of those existing within them. Therefore, the suggestion is that narrative analysis could provide a tool for ethnographers to better understand the role of incorporating participants’ stories and understandings of their spaces and places within the ethnographic study. This paper is helpful then in demonstrating a rationale as well as a means for ethnographers to incorporate narrative analysis into their methodologies.

Herman, L., & Vervaeck, B. (2005). Handbook of narrative analysis. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.

In this handbook, the authors define a variety of narrative theories and illuminate the potential benefits and limitations of each. The authors divide the book into three chapters based upon major narrative theoretical constructs: “Before and Surrounding Structuralism,” “Structuralism,” and “Post-Classical Narratology”. Within each chapter, the authors begin by providing the history and development of each theory as well as concrete understandings of how academics, researchers, and theorists alike would approach narrative analysis from their varied perspectives depending upon their narrative theory alignment. For example, the authors explain how classical structuralists and post-classicists approach narrative analysis differently, and they use two stories as models for demonstrating the different nuanced approaches to narrative analysis (p. 103). This text serves as a useful tool for those looking to engage in narrative analysis but struggling to understand its varied theoretical underpinnings and how they inform one’s approach to narrative analysis. however, for those looking for a basic definition and understanding of approaches to narrative analysis, this predominantly theoretical text may prove cumbersome.

Josselson, R. and Lieblich, A. (1999). Making meaning of narratives. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

In this book, the authors present readers with ten essays that explore the use of narrative analysis within a variety of disciplines, including literary studies, nursing, criminology, sociology, and psychology. The first essay, unlike the other nine, begins by elucidating the issues, both methodological and ethical, that researchers may face by using people’s stories as their primary and/or only source of data, and it helps readers understand the notion of narratives telling many different truths. The other nine essays provide examples of narrative analysis research within specific disciplines. The strengths of this book are that it helps researchers conceptualize the varied ways in which narrative analysis can be applied and to think critically about the “multiple truths” that can be explored through narrative analysis. Thus, if one is less interested in the history of narrative analysis or multiple definitions of narrative analysis, but instead wants to see examples of narrative analysis in action, this book will prove useful.

Kim, J.-H. (2016). Understanding narrative inquiry: The crafting and analysis of stories as research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

This textbook provides both a theoretical and methodological understanding of narrative inquiry as a qualitative research theory and methodology. The book begins by exploring the many disciplines in which narrative inquiry can be employed and the theoretical underpinnings behind narrative inquiry. After providing a wealth of theoretical lenses for which researchers might employ narrative inquiry, Dr. Kim then provides explicit feedback on how one should engage in data collection and analysis using narrative inquiry; the book ends by addressing critical issues to consider as narrative researchers and including examples of narrative inquiry in action. Therefore, this textbook provides a thorough examination of narrative inquiry through both theoretical and methodological lenses, and it is highly recommended for any qualitative researcher interested in engaging in narrative research.

Recent Dissertations Using Narrative Analysis Methodology

Njoku, N. R. (2017). Woman in the making: The impact of the constructed campus environment of Xavier University of Louisiana on the construction of Black womanhood. Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (Order Number 10637092)

This study adopts a narrative analysis approach as a means for giving voice to African American woman attending Xavier University of Louisiana. Through a narrative analysis approach, participants’ perspectives were not contrasted to others, but rather highlighted individually. The narrative inquiry approach is centered within Black feminist epistemology and works toward telling the stories of each participant. The research questions guiding this research are:

1. How do African American women construct Black womanhood?
2. What role does the HBCU [historically Black colleges and universities] campus environment play in facilitating these constructions of Black womanhood? (p. 6)

Participants were alumni of Xavier University who identified as both African-American and cisgender women. The data were initially gathered through in-depth interviews to establish a timeline and develop a relationship between researcher and participant. For the second aspect of data collection, participants were asked to compose a timeline of their lives, combining pictures with the narrative. This then was used as a prompt for further reflection as each participant shared stories about the pictures along the timeline. One implication of this study is that research that conflates Black men muffles the voices of the women, who have their own narratives and experiences to share. The lack of nuance between groups lessens the chances that the needs of these women will be met in their academic endeavors.

Petrone, D. (2016). A narrative analysis of women’s desires and contributions to community, sentience, agency and transformation: A narrative analysis. Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (Order Number 10146171)

The goal of this dissertation is to explore the ways that women and their community develop agency. A perspective of critical literacy and narrative inquiry create a space where participants explore and grow; the assumption remains that “humanity is not finished” (p. ii), which allows for continued growth and development.

Within this study, narrative analysis is utilized along with a critical approach to disrupt ideas of power. Within a narrative analysis view, the narrative is seen as data, and a stance of embracing change that connects the words to the world is adopted. Additionally, the idea of highlighting the connection or collaboration between researcher and participant is important throughout this study. Data were gathered through a focus group comprised largely of friends or acquaintances of the researcher who shared a sense of “unfinishedness” (p. 51), which then allowed for a connection based on common sharing and support. Interviews were the primary source of data, both within the larger focus group and then with individuals. The implications of this study are in the possibility for human development, specifically in relation to internal growth, as individuals work to read, and interact with, the world.

Wingfield, M. V. (2018). Becoming all that I can be: Narrative analysis of African-American students’ literacy perceptions and experiences in an urban Title I school. Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (Order Number 10784392)

Within in this study, students’ writing, specifically poetry, is analyzed for its narrative connections to the students’ own lives. This allows for students’ narratives to disrupt the deficit approach frequently connected with research around Title I schools by acknowledging their “culturally situated literacies, opinions, and academic potential for success” (p. 72). More specifically, the purpose of this study is to explore students’ perceptions of literacy experiences through high school. The research questions guiding this study are:

1. How do African-American high school graduates from a low-income urban community school describe their high school literacy experiences?
2. How do African-American students perceive the ways in which their literacy experiences were culturally responsive by addressing their varied literacy practices? (p. 16)

Narrative analysis was adopted to explore a critical approach and culturally responsive pedagogy. Data were gathered through interviews and artifacts that included books, photos, and the senior portfolio. These data were analyzed as points within a story, or as part of the participants’ narrative of their experience. The implications of this study are support of culturally responsive pedagogy and critical literacies in Title I schools.

Internet Resources

Centre for Narrative Research’s Blog (https://centrefornarrativeresearch.wordpress.com/2018/02/16/centre-for-narrative-research-spring-summer-2018-events/)

The Centre for Narrative Research Blog offers an up-to-date blog from The University of East London’s School of Social Sciences with events around the world, which narrative researchers could attend.

The Australian Department of Defense: “A Review of Narrative Methodology” Bibliography PDF (http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/css506/506%20readings/review%20of%20narritive%20methodology%20australian%20gov.pdf)

The Australian Department of Defense: Defense, Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO) published an annotated bibliography titled “A Review of Narrative Methodology.” The DTSO cites many publications of narrative methodology research that study human action. The executive summary that starts the bibliography provides a clear definition of narrative inquiry and its historical background.

Narrative Inquiry: What’s Your Story? (http://qualitativeresearchontario.openetext.utoronto.ca/chapter/video-module-3-doing-qualitative-research/)

A research guide from The University of Western Ontario provides video lectures pertaining to qualitative research.  Scroll down to a video lecture, entitled, “Narrative Inquiry: What’s Your Story?” from Dr. Debbie Laliberte Rudman of The University of Western Ontario. The resource also includes a list of suggested readings.

Professional Organizations and Conferences

The following associations and conferences have a focus on Narrative Inquiry. They serve as a venue for presenting current research.  They also serve as additional points for researchers to develop their understanding of and collaboration within the field of Narrative Inquiry.

The American Educational Resource Association (AERA) has a specific webpage for narrative research resources, which includes a YouTube Video of Vivian Gussin Paley’s discussion “How can we study the narrative of play when the children are given so little time to play?”, book suggestions with annotations, resources sorted by journals, books, teachers, multicultural, feminism, identity, qualitative books that include narrative research, specific journal articles, websites, and notes and comments from our members.

• AERA Narrative Research SIG Website (https://sites.google.com/site/aeranarrativeresearchsig/home/resources-1)
• The International Society for the Study of Narrative is an organization with an annual conference. http://narrative.georgetown.edu/conferences/
• Narrative Matters is a biannual conference on narrative analysis. The 2018 conference was held at the University of Twente in the Netherlands. https://www.utwente.nl/en/bms/narrativematters2018/